In this article
The short answer
Start from the batch sheet. Break every blend and carrier into its ingredients, merge duplicates, and sort by weight as added. Everything at 1% or more stays in strict descending order; below 1% you may list in any order. Add Parfum by its weight and name the allergens above threshold. Put colourants other than hair dyes in their own block at the end, with "may contain" or "+/-" for a shade range, and head it all "Ingredients".
Key takeaways
- In Great Britain the rule is Article 19(1)(g) of the GB Regulation. The exit amendments left point (g) untouched, so the order rules match the EU text.
- Work from the batch sheet. Supplier blends, preservative systems and extract carriers are broken into their ingredients and weighed as added.
- An ingredient that comes from two raw materials, such as glycerin from an extract carrier, is listed once at its combined weight.
- OPSS describes the ordered group as ingredients at "1% or more", so keep anything at exactly 1% in strict weight order.
- Named allergens go in addition to Parfum. The law fixes no position, and because they are almost always under 1% they usually sit at the end of the free-order tail.
- For a shade range, OPSS reserves the may contain block for colourants. Varying non-colour ingredients go in the main list.
Most ingredient list problems we see in label reviews are not about knowing the rules. Founders can usually recite them: heaviest first, the 1% rule, colourants at the end. The errors creep in during the translation from a batch sheet full of trade names and supplier blends to a single line of text on a carton. A preservative blend gets listed as one ingredient. Glycerin appears twice. A hydrosol is split into water and rose when it has a name of its own. Every individual rule was known; the list is still wrong.
So this guide does something different from our overview of cosmetic ingredient lists and INCI names. We take one face cream formula and walk it all the way from the batch sheet to the printed list, under the rules as they apply in Great Britain, and then do the same for a lip tint sold in six shades. If you need the background on the names themselves, start with what INCI stands for, and for checking a name or an annex entry, see our walkthrough of CosIng. Here we are only interested in getting the list itself right.
The GB legal text, and what changed after Brexit
In Great Britain the rule lives in Article 19(1)(g) of the GB version of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009, enforced through the Cosmetic Products Enforcement Regulations 2013. The exit amendments to Article 19 were made by Schedule 34, paragraph 18 of the Product Safety and Metrology etc. (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019. They changed the Responsible Person address wording, the rules for unpackaged products, the language rule and a cross-reference in paragraph 6. They did not touch point (g). The ordering rules you apply in Great Britain are, word for word, the ones that were in force across the EU before exit, and legislation.gov.uk currently records no outstanding changes to Article 19.
The operative words are worth reading once in full. The list "shall be established in descending order of weight of the ingredients at the time they are added to the cosmetic product. Ingredients in concentrations of less than 1 % may be listed in any order after those in concentrations of more than 1 %." Colorants other than those intended to colour the hair "may be listed in any order after the other cosmetic ingredients", and the list "shall be preceded by the term 'ingredients'".
Two GB-specific details matter for the carton. First, the language rule in regulation 5(3) of the Enforcement Regulations requires English for the function, precautions, durability and quantity information, but it does not list point (g). The ingredient names are not translated: you print the glossary names, so it is Aqua and Butyrospermum Parkii Butter, not "water" and "shea butter". Second, the OPSS guidance on the GB Regulation (updated 29 June 2026) accepts an alternative name in brackets where INCI names differ between regions, giving "water (aqua)", "aqua (water)" and "CI 14700 (Red 4)" as examples. That is a UK statement. If the same carton is going into the EU, check the bracketed form with your EU Responsible Person.
Step 1: start from the batch sheet, not the marketing list
Here is the batch sheet for a simple rose day cream, as a contract manufacturer would send it. It is illustrative, but every structure in it is one we meet weekly. The right-hand column is the job: turning each raw material into the ingredients the law asks you to declare.
| Raw material on the batch sheet | % added | What goes on the label |
|---|---|---|
| Purified water | 63.45 | AQUA 63.45 |
| Rose hydrosol (supplier spec: 99.8% rose flower water, 0.2% sodium benzoate) | 10.00 | ROSA DAMASCENA FLOWER WATER 9.98, SODIUM BENZOATE 0.02 |
| Caprylic/capric triglyceride | 8.00 | CAPRYLIC/CAPRIC TRIGLYCERIDE 8.00 |
| Glycerin | 4.00 | GLYCERIN 4.00 |
| Olive-derived emulsifier, sold under a trade name (spec: 60% cetearyl olivate, 40% sorbitan olivate) | 5.00 | CETEARYL OLIVATE 3.00, SORBITAN OLIVATE 2.00 |
| Shea butter | 3.00 | BUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTER 3.00 |
| Cetearyl alcohol | 2.50 | CETEARYL ALCOHOL 2.50 |
| Aloe extract in glycerin (spec: 20% extract, 80% glycerin) | 2.00 | ALOE BARBADENSIS LEAF EXTRACT 0.40, GLYCERIN 1.60 |
| Preservative blend (spec: 90% phenoxyethanol, 10% ethylhexylglycerin) | 1.00 | PHENOXYETHANOL 0.90, ETHYLHEXYLGLYCERIN 0.10 |
| Fragrance compound (allergen statement: linalool 2.4%, limonene 1.6% of the compound) | 0.50 | PARFUM 0.50, plus LINALOOL 0.012 and LIMONENE 0.008 named separately |
| Xanthan gum | 0.30 | XANTHAN GUM 0.30 |
| Tocopherol | 0.20 | TOCOPHEROL 0.20 |
| Citric acid (pH adjustment) | 0.05 | CITRIC ACID 0.05 |
Notice what had to happen on almost half the lines.
- Blends are broken down. The emulsifier sold under a trade name is two ingredients, and the preservative blend is two more. The OPSS guidance says it plainly: mixtures must be broken down into their individual components. You need the supplier's composition to do it, which is why a specification sheet matters more than a brochure.
- Carriers count. The aloe extract arrived in glycerin, and that glycerin was intentionally put into your product. It is declared, and it is weighed as it was added: 80% of 2.00 is 1.60.
- The same ingredient is listed once. Glycerin now comes from two raw materials. It is one ingredient, so it appears once, at its combined 5.60%. Listing it twice, or at 4.00% only, puts it in the wrong place.
- A hydrosol is usually one ingredient. The 2025 glossary has its own names for many floral waters, such as ROSA DAMASCENA FLOWER WATER and HAMAMELIS VIRGINIANA WATER. Do not split the hydrosol into Aqua plus the plant. Check the exact name against the plant part and process on the specification.
- The preservative in the hydrosol is declared. The supplier added sodium benzoate to the rose water on purpose. Impurities and processing aids that are not present in the final product are excluded from the list by Article 19, but a preservative added to a raw material is neither. The safe reading, and the one inspectors expect, is to declare it.
Put every line on the same basis, percentage by weight of the whole batch, before you sort anything. Mixing grams, kilos and percentages on one sheet is the quickest way to produce a list that looks plausible and is not.
Step 2: sort by weight, and draw the 1% line
Now sort. Everything at 1% and above goes in strict descending order of weight as added. Then draw a line, because below it the law lets you choose.
| Position | Ingredient | % in product | Why it sits here |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Aqua | 63.45 | Heaviest ingredient as added |
| 2 | Rosa Damascena Flower Water | 9.98 | The hydrosol has its own glossary name, so it is one ingredient, not water plus rose |
| 3 | Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride | 8.00 | Weight order |
| 4 | Glycerin | 5.60 | 4.00 added directly plus 1.60 from the aloe carrier, listed once |
| 5 and 6 | Butyrospermum Parkii Butter, Cetearyl Olivate | 3.00 each | A tie. Either order is defensible; record the one you chose |
| 7 | Cetearyl Alcohol | 2.50 | Weight order |
| 8 | Sorbitan Olivate | 2.00 | Last ingredient above the 1% line |
| 9 onwards | Phenoxyethanol, Parfum, Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Extract, Xanthan Gum, Tocopherol, Ethylhexylglycerin, Citric Acid, Sodium Benzoate, Linalool, Limonene | under 1% each | Free order is allowed here. We kept descending weight and put the named allergens last, after Parfum |
Three judgement calls are hiding in that table, and they are the ones people ask us about.
What about an ingredient at exactly 1%? Read the regulation literally and it does not say. It frees ingredients "less than 1 %" and refers to those "more than 1 %", leaving exactly 1% in neither group. The OPSS guidance closes the gap by describing the ordered group as ingredients "in concentrations of 1% or more". So in Great Britain, keep an ingredient at exactly 1.00% in the ordered part of the list. That is also the cautious reading anywhere else.
What about ties? Shea butter and cetearyl olivate are both at 3.00%. The regulation has no tie-break rule, so either order is defensible. Pick one, write down why, and keep it consistent across reprints.
Do I have to use the freedom below 1%? No. It is permissive. We often keep descending order in the tail anyway, because it is easier to audit and it stops the list drifting between reprints. What you cannot do is use the tail to promote a hero active. The OPSS guidance on claims expects that if you claim the presence of a specific ingredient, it was deliberately added, and that ingredient benefits are not stretched into product benefits without evidence. Moving aloe to the front of the sub-1% block changes neither fact. Our article on compliant labels, claims and warnings covers claim support.
Keep the 1% line live, too. If a reformulation moves sorbitan olivate from 2.00% to 0.95%, it drops into the tail and the whole printed list can change. That is the most common reason a label that was right at launch is wrong a year later.
Step 3: parfum and the allergens you must name
The fragrance compound goes on the list as Parfum (or Aroma for a flavour), placed by the weight at which the compound was added. Here that is 0.50%, so it sits in the sub-1% tail.
Some fragrance substances then have to be named as well, in addition to Parfum. Article 19 requires this for substances whose mention is required in the "Other" column of Annex III, and the OPSS guidance gives the thresholds: above 0.001% in leave-on products and 0.01% in rinse-off products. Work them out from the supplier's allergen statement. In our cream, linalool at 2.4% of a compound used at 0.5% gives 0.012% in the product, and limonene at 1.6% gives 0.008%. Both are above 0.001% in a leave-on cream, so both are named.
Where do they go? The law only says they are indicated in addition to Parfum. It does not fix a position. Because named allergens are almost always well under 1%, they fall in the free-order tail, and many brands put them at the end of it, straight after Parfum or after the last ingredient, so a sensitised reader can find them. That is what we did.
Which substances you have to name depends on the market. Great Britain has not adopted the EU's expanded list: the GB Annex III on legislation.gov.uk, checked in November 2026, still carries the original group of named fragrance allergens, linalool and limonene among them. The EU expanded its list to more than 80 entries through Regulation (EU) 2023/1545, and Northern Ireland follows the EU. Our guides to labelling fragrance allergens and the EU allergen changes for 2026 to 2028 explain the dates and the one-label option for brands selling in both markets.
Step 4: names, nano and the final check
Every line now gets its common ingredient name. In Great Britain, Article 19(6) points to the glossary that the Secretary of State must publish under Article 33(4), and the OPSS guidance tells you to use the common (INCI) name, with fallbacks such as the chemical name, CAS number or Colour Index number only where no INCI name exists. For a label shared with Northern Ireland or the EU, check each name against the EU glossary, currently Implementing Decision (EU) 2025/1175, listed on the Commission's glossary page. Capital letters are not required; many brands print the names in title case for legibility.
If any ingredient is present as a nanomaterial, the word nano goes in brackets straight after its name, for example Titanium Dioxide (nano). The bracket changes nothing about position: the ingredient is still ordered by weight. Our article on nanomaterials in cosmetics covers the notification side.
The finished list for the rose day cream reads:
Ingredients: Aqua, Rosa Damascena Flower Water, Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride, Glycerin, Butyrospermum Parkii Butter, Cetearyl Olivate, Cetearyl Alcohol, Sorbitan Olivate, Phenoxyethanol, Parfum, Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Extract, Xanthan Gum, Tocopherol, Ethylhexylglycerin, Citric Acid, Sodium Benzoate, Linalool, Limonene.
Before it goes to the designer, read it back against the sorted spreadsheet, line by line. Then check the heading: the word has to be "Ingredients". "Full INCI", "Formula" or "What's inside" can sit nearby as decoration, but they do not replace it.
Worked example 2: a lip tint in six shades
Colour changes the method. Article 19 lets colourants other than hair colourants come out of the weight order and sit together after everything else, in any order, identified by their CI number where one applies. And for decorative products marketed in several colour shades, all the colourants used in the range may be listed on one label, provided "may contain" or "+/-" is added. The OPSS guidance defines decorative cosmetics as products meant to change the appearance of the area they are applied to, usually with colour: lipstick, eye shadow, blusher and eye pencil are its examples.
Say the six shades share a base of castor oil, beeswax, carnauba wax, jojoba oil, tocopherol and a flavour, and between them use five colourants. One shared list could read:
Ingredients: Ricinus Communis Seed Oil, Cera Alba, Copernicia Cerifera Cera, Simmondsia Chinensis Seed Oil, Tocopherol, Aroma. May contain (+/-): CI 15850, CI 77491, CI 77492, CI 77499, CI 77891.
The flavour is declared as Aroma, and if it contains allergens above threshold they are named too. Each colourant must be in Annex IV and allowed for lips. The GB Annex IV marks some colourants "not to be used in products applied on mucous membranes", and those cannot go in a lip product, so check the field-of-application column before a colour goes into the range. Our article on colourants, mica and glitter under Annex IV walks through those columns.
Two practical points from the OPSS guidance are worth knowing, because they settle arguments we hear in almost every colour project:
- Varying non-colour ingredients. Shades often need small base changes to carry different pigments. The Regulation has no provision for this, and a strict reading would mean a separate list for each shade. OPSS records that the accepted industry practice is to put those variable non-colour ingredients in the main body of the list. The may contain section stays reserved for colourants.
- Colour ingredients without a CI number. OPSS notes that the industry interpretation is to list ingredients closely associated with colour, but without a CI number in Annex IV, under the may contain section where they are only in some shades.
The shared list is a labelling convenience, not a documentation shortcut. Each shade still needs its actual formula in the Product Information File and has to be covered by the safety assessment. When a shade is added or discontinued, update the colourant block on the next print run.
Hair colourants are the exception inside the exception. Colourants intended to colour the hair stay in the weight order with everything else, and oxidative hair dyes carry their own warnings, covered in our post on hair dye labelling and CPSRs.
Where the list has to appear on UK packs
A correct list in the wrong place is still a labelling failure. This matters most for small makers selling soap at markets or products packed to order.
| Situation | Where the list goes | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Normal pre-packaged product | On the outer packaging. It may appear on the packaging alone, or on the container if there is no outer pack | Article 19(1)(g); OPSS guidance para 111 |
| Too small or awkward to print the list | On an enclosed or attached leaflet, label, tape, tag or card, with the hand-and-book symbol (or abbreviated text) on the packaging pointing to it | Article 19(2); Annex VII point 1 |
| Soap, bath balls and other small products where even a tag is impractical | On a notice in immediate proximity to the container the product is displayed in | Article 19(3) |
| Not pre-packaged, or packed at the customer's request | On the container in which it is displayed, or on a notice in immediate proximity to it | Article 19(4); Enforcement Regulations 2013, reg 5(1) |
| Pre-packaged for immediate sale | On an attached label, tag, tape or card, or an enclosed leaflet; if impossible, a notice beside the display container | Enforcement Regulations 2013, reg 5(2) |
The rest of the mandatory label (Responsible Person, nominal content, durability or PAO, warnings, batch, function) sits around the list. Our label review checklist and the guide to net quantity and batch codes cover those, and our post on mandatory warnings and statements explains why warnings never go inside the ingredient list.
One list for GB, Northern Ireland and the EU?
Usually, yes, because the ordering rules are the same. Northern Ireland applies the EU Regulation under the Windsor Framework, and the EU text of point (g) is the same as the GB one. What differs is which ingredients you may use and at what level (the GB annexes are now amended by GB statutory instruments), which fragrance allergens you have to name, and which glossary reference applies. So the order rarely forces two labels, but the allergen list and the annexes sometimes do. Our guide to one CPSR for the UK and EU covers the paperwork side, and our Northern Ireland post explains why NI sits with the EU.
Whatever you decide, keep the working file: the batch sheet, the breakdown of each blend, the sorted spreadsheet with the 1% line marked, and the allergen calculation. When Trading Standards or a retailer asks how you got your list, that file is the answer, and it means the next reformulation is a ten-minute update rather than a reprint you discover too late.
Want the list checked against your batch sheet before it goes to print?
Send us the artwork and the quantitative formula, including supplier specifications for any blends. We rebuild the list from the batch sheet, confirm every name, check where the 1% line falls, place parfum, allergens and colourants correctly, and tell you whether your shade range can share one printed list in Great Britain, Northern Ireland and the EU.
Related reading
- Cosmetic ingredient lists and INCI names explained
- What does INCI stand for?
- How to use CosIng: a step-by-step walkthrough
- How to label fragrance allergens
- Colourants, mica and glitter under Annex IV
- Cosmetic labelling requirements: 14 things to check before printing
- All regulatory compliance articles
Myths we hear
- A supplier blend can go on the label under one name. Mixtures are broken down into their individual components. A preservative blend or an emulsifier sold under a trade name becomes two or more ingredients, each placed by its own weight.
- If glycerin is in two raw materials, it appears twice. It is one ingredient. Add the amounts together and list it once, at the combined weight.
- Ingredients at exactly 1% can go anywhere. The GB guidance treats 1% or more as the ordered group. Keep anything at exactly 1% in strict weight order.
- Allergens have to be placed by their own weight. The law only requires them to be named in addition to Parfum. Being under 1% in almost every product, they sit in the free-order tail, often at the end.
- May contain covers anything that varies between shades. OPSS reserves it for colourants. Non-colour ingredients that vary between shades go in the main body of the list.
- Ingredient names have to be translated into English for the UK. The English rule covers other label information, not the ingredient list. You print the common ingredient (INCI) names, and OPSS accepts a bracketed alternative such as Aqua (Water).
What to do this week
- Get the final batch sheet and confirm it matches the formula in your Product Information File.
- Ask suppliers for the full composition of every blend, carrier and preserved raw material.
- Convert every line to percentage by weight of the batch, then break each raw material into its ingredients.
- Merge duplicate ingredients and sort by weight as added. Mark the 1% line and keep anything at exactly 1% above it.
- Add Parfum or Aroma by its weight, calculate allergen levels from the supplier statement, and name those above threshold.
- Move colourants (not hair dyes) into a block at the end, with may contain or +/if a shade range shares the list.
- Check every name against the glossary, add (nano) where it applies, and head the list Ingredients.
- File the working spreadsheet with the PIF, and redo it whenever the formula changes.
Frequently asked questions
What order does a UK cosmetic ingredient list follow?
Descending order of weight at the time each ingredient is added to the product. Ingredients under 1% may follow in any order. Colourants other than hair dyes may be listed together, in any order, after all the other ingredients. This comes from Article 19(1)(g) of the GB Regulation.
Where does an ingredient at exactly 1% go?
Keep it in the strictly ordered part of the list. The regulation frees ingredients under 1% and does not mention exactly 1%, but the OPSS guidance for Great Britain describes the ordered group as ingredients at 1% or more.
How do I list a supplier's blend or an extract in a carrier?
Break it into its components using the supplier's specification, and weigh each one as added. An extract supplied in glycerin becomes the extract plus glycerin. If glycerin is already in the formula, add the two amounts and list it once.
Where do fragrance allergens go on the list?
They are named in addition to Parfum when present above 0.001% in leave-on or 0.01% in rinse-off products. The law does not fix their position. As they are almost always under 1%, they usually sit in the free-order tail, often at the end.
Can one ingredient list cover several shades?
Yes, for decorative products such as lipstick or eye shadow. List all the colourants used across the range after the other ingredients, with may contain or +/-. OPSS says non-colour ingredients that vary between shades go in the main body of the list.
Do ingredient names have to be in English in the UK?
No. The English requirement covers other label information, not the ingredient list. Use the common ingredient (INCI) names, such as Aqua. OPSS accepts a bracketed alternative where names differ between regions, for example Aqua (Water).
Does the list need a heading?
Yes. Article 19 says the list must be preceded by the term ingredients. Words such as Full INCI or Formula can appear nearby but do not replace it.
Can I use the same ingredient list in Great Britain, Northern Ireland and the EU?
Often, because the ordering rules are the same and Northern Ireland follows the EU Regulation. The differences are in permitted ingredients, the fragrance allergens you must name and the glossary reference, so check those before sharing one label.
Official sources and legislation
- Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 as it applies in Great Britain, Article 19 (labelling), legislation.gov.uk
- Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009, Article 19, original text as adopted by the EU
- Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 as it applies in Great Britain, Article 33 (glossary reference)
- Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 as it applies in Great Britain, Annex IV (colourants)
- Product Safety and Metrology etc. (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019, Schedule 34 (paragraph 18 amends Article 19)
- Cosmetic Products Enforcement Regulations 2013, regulation 5 (labelling and English language)
- OPSS: Regulation 1223/2009 and the Cosmetic Products Enforcement Regulations 2013, Great Britain (updated 29 June 2026)
- Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 as it applies in Great Britain, Annex III (restricted substances, including fragrance allergens)
- GOV.UK: Making cosmetic products available to consumers in Great Britain
- European Commission: CosIng glossary of ingredients, listing Implementing Decision (EU) 2025/1175
Join the conversation