Skip to content
Qualified safety assessorsUK · EU · USA
Get a quote
  1. Home
  2. BLOGS
  3. Influencer Cosmetic Claims Rules in the UK: Why a Caption Cannot Promise More Than the Pack

Influencer Cosmetic Claims Rules in the UK: Why a Caption Cannot Promise More Than the Pack

The carton is the ceiling. Anything a creator says above it is a claim somebody has to prove, and that somebody is usually the brand

S Syed Muhammad Shamuel SheesFounder & Lead Compliance Consultant
15 min read
Reviewed by Phoenix Cosmetic Safety · Nov 19, 2026
A woman filming a makeup tutorial in a home studio, like a beauty influencer.

The short answer

A claim about a cosmetic in a social media post, reel, comment reply or affiliate link is judged exactly like a claim on the pack. It must meet the common criteria in Regulation (EU) No 655/2013, be backed by evidence held in the Product Information File, and the Responsible Person carries that obligation, not the creator. On top of that, UK advertising and consumer law require the post to be labelled clearly as an ad, and reviews to reflect genuine use.

Key takeaways

  • The cosmetics claims rules cover advertising expressly, so a caption, a video and a comment reply are judged like the carton.
  • A creator is a channel, not a shield. The Responsible Person's duty to hold proof of the claimed effect does not move to whoever wrote the post.
  • UK posts also answer to the CAP Code and, since 6 April 2025, the DMCC Act, under which the CMA can fine directly up to 10% of global turnover.
  • Claims inflate as they travel. Treatment language at the end of a creator chain is a classification problem, not just a wording problem.
  • Filters on the area a product affects, unverified before-and-afters and reviews of products the creator has not used are all known enforcement points.
  • An approved-wording list and a named prohibited list in the brief prevent far more trouble than reviewing posts after they go live.

We get a version of this message regularly: a screenshot and one line, "Is this a problem?" Picture a creator's story, filmed in a bathroom mirror, holding up a barrier cream. The caption reads: "Two weeks and my eczema is GONE." The carton says "formulated to support the skin barrier". Nobody at the brand wrote the caption, approved it or saw it before it went up. They sent the product, a discount code and a two-line brief.

Yes, it is a problem, and it is the brand's. Influencer cosmetic claims rules in the UK are not a separate, softer regime. A caption is judged like a carton. If a statement about what a cosmetic does would need evidence on the pack, it needs the same evidence in a reel, and the party expected to hold that evidence is the brand behind the product. What makes social media harder is volume and distance: you see your carton before it prints, but you may be mentioned in hundreds of posts you never commissioned and dozens you did.

This guide is written for brands and the people who run their creator programmes. It covers the rules a post has to pass, who carries the risk, how claims drift as they move along a chain of people, what the October 2026 labelling guide changed, and the brief wording that prevents most of the trouble before it starts.

Why a caption is a cosmetic claim

Article 20 of the Cosmetics Regulation is short and deliberately wide. In the labelling, making available on the market and advertising of cosmetic products, "text, names, trade marks, pictures and figurative or other signs" must not imply characteristics or functions the product does not have. Advertising is named in the article itself. A sponsored reel is advertising. So is a pinned testimonial on your product page and a boosted post from a creator's account.

The common criteria in Regulation (EU) No 655/2013 then set the standard every claim has to meet: legal compliance, truthfulness, evidential support, honesty, fairness, and informed decision-making. Two lines in that annex could have been written for social media. Under honesty: "Presentations of a product's performance shall not go beyond the available supporting evidence." Under truthfulness: marketing communications "shall not imply that expressions of opinions are verified claims unless the opinion reflects verifiable evidence." That second one is the testimonial rule in a sentence.

Great Britain applies both texts in their assimilated form, and adds something useful in its version of Article 20(2): "A responsible person must ensure that the wording of any claim in relation to a cosmetic product is in compliance with the common criteria." As checked on 19 November 2026, legislation.gov.uk shows no outstanding changes to either text. Northern Ireland follows the EU versions.

None of this distinguishes between media. A still image, a spoken sentence, an on-screen overlay, a before-and-after pair and a product tag in a shoppable post are all ways of presenting the product. Our guide to the six common criteria and how to substantiate them works through each criterion. The practical test does not change: could you produce the evidence if asked, and does the overall impression match it?

The four rule sets a creator post has to pass

Cosmetics law decides whether a claim is true and supported. It says nothing about whether a post is recognisable as an ad, or about fake reviews. Those come from advertising and consumer law, which apply on top. A single creator post in the UK is answerable to all of these at once:

Rule setWhat it asks of a creator postWho enforces it
Cosmetics Regulation, Article 20, and the common criteria in Regulation (EU) No 655/2013 (GB assimilated versions)No text, picture or sign in labelling, making available or advertising may imply characteristics the product does not have. Every claim must meet the six common criteria, and in GB the Responsible Person must ensure claim wording complies with themTrading Standards in Great Britain, under the Cosmetic Products Enforcement Regulations 2013. Northern Ireland follows the EU texts
CAP Code (non-broadcast advertising)Ads must be obviously identifiable (rule 2.1) and must not hide commercial intent (2.3). Objective claims need documentary evidence before publication (3.7). Testimonials must be genuine and on file (3.47). No false claims to treat disease (12.6), and "cure" is not generally acceptable for cosmetics (12.7)Advertising Standards Authority (ASA)
Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Part 4 Chapter 1 and Schedule 20Bans misleading and other unfair commercial practices, fake or concealed-incentive reviews, and posing as a consumer. Applies to practices from 6 April 2025, replacing the 2008 Unfair Trading RegulationsCompetition and Markets Authority (directly, with fines up to 10% of global turnover) and Trading Standards
Medicines lawA product presented as treating or preventing disease risks being treated as a medicine, whatever the formulaMHRA

The consumer law row is the one that changed most recently. Since 6 April 2025 the unfair commercial practices rules sit in Part 4, Chapter 1 of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, which revoked and replaced the Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008. The CMA guidance on unfair commercial practices says most of the old requirements carry over. The big difference is enforcement: the CMA can now decide for itself that the law has been broken and, as its announcement of the new regime put it, fine a company up to 10% of its global turnover. Before that, only a court could decide that a practice was unfair.

The CAP Code rules on health and beauty also make the medicinal line explicit. Rule 12.6 says marketers should not falsely claim a product can prevent or treat disease, and rule 12.7 says unqualified claims such as "cure" and "rejuvenation" are not generally acceptable, "especially for cosmetic products". Under rule 3.7, the evidence has to be held before the ad goes out, not gathered after a complaint.

In the EU, the cosmetics texts are the same, advertising is policed under each member state's national rules, and the Commission still lists the Technical document on cosmetic claims (version of 3 July 2017) as its reference guidance. It is a non-binding best-practice tool rather than law, but national authorities use it.

Who is liable when a creator overstates

The Responsible Person named on the label has to keep a Product Information File which, under Article 11, includes "proof of the effect claimed for the cosmetic product" where the nature or effect of the product justifies it. That obligation attaches to the product. It does not move to whoever typed a caption.

So where a brand commissions, briefs, pays, gifts, scripts or approves content, the content is in substance the brand's advertising, and the brand is the party expected to back it up. The advertising rules say the same thing from their side. The joint ASA, CAP and CMA influencer guide states that the influencer, the brand and any agents involved are all responsible for making sure content is properly labelled, and that everyone in the chain is responsible for following the law. The ASA treats content as an ad it can rule on when the brand has paid the creator in some way and had some editorial control, and "payment" includes free product, whether requested or not.

A contract that makes the creator responsible for their own compliance is worth having. It allocates risk between two private parties. It does not change what the Responsible Person has to hold, and it will not stop a regulator writing to the brand.

Organic content is different in degree rather than kind. Nobody expects you to police every mention of your product. What you are expected to avoid is adopting a claim you could not make yourself. Resharing, quoting, pinning, embedding on the product page or running a post as paid media takes the wording on as yours, however it started.

How claims inflate on the way down the chain

We see the same pattern often enough to predict it. Each person in the chain makes a small change, and nobody believes they invented a new claim.

StageWhat it saysWhat went wrong
Carton"Formulated to support the skin barrier"Nothing. This is the claim the evidence file was built for
Agency brief"Strengthens the skin barrier"A hedged formulation claim has become an unhedged performance claim
Creator video"Repaired my barrier in two weeks"A timescale has appeared that no study supports, and one person's result reads as everyone's
Affiliate repost"Cleared my eczema"A cosmetic benefit has become treatment of a named condition. This is now a classification problem, not a wording one
Comment reply"Yes, it's safe for anyone with allergies"A tolerance claim has become a promise nobody reacts, which no test can support

The affiliate row is the dangerous one. A product presented as treating or preventing disease may fall outside the cosmetic definition altogether and be treated as a medicine, which is a different authorisation route. No amount of evidence about moisturisation fixes that. Our guide to borderline product classification explains where the line sits, and our piece on anti-wrinkle products and the medicine line shows how quickly ordinary skincare language crosses it.

The comment row is a tolerance claim that has lost its qualifier. "Allergy tested" means a study was run; it never means nobody reacts. Our posts on the evidence behind an allergy tested claim and what dermatologist tested actually means set out what those words can and cannot carry.

Before-and-afters, filters and testimonials

Visual claims are claims. A before-and-after pair says the product produced the difference between the two images, and that is a performance claim needing evidence. The usual failures are uncontrolled variables rather than dishonesty: different lighting, a different angle, makeup in one frame, a different time of day, or a gap during which the person also changed three other things.

Filters are a known enforcement point. In February 2021 the ASA upheld complaints against two tanning brands whose influencers had used Instagram beauty filters that altered their skin tone and complexion. Because the filter's effect was directly relevant to what the product claimed to do, the ASA found it exaggerated the product's efficacy, in breach of the CAP Code rules on misleading advertising and exaggeration. Its note on beauty filters in cosmetic ads adds two points brands tend to miss: responsibility ultimately lies with the advertiser, and because filters are applied as content is created, there is usually no "before" footage to prove the result was not exaggerated. The CAP advice on production techniques in cosmetic ads applies the same logic to retouching.

Testimonials sit under two sets of rules. The cosmetics criteria say an opinion must not be presented as a verified result. The CAP Code adds, at rule 3.47, that marketers must hold documentary evidence that a testimonial is genuine and hold contact details for the person who gave it. And Schedule 20 of the DMCC Act now lists, as banned outright, submitting or commissioning a fake consumer review or one that conceals it was incentivised. The October 2026 influencer guide spells this out for creators: a review has to reflect the creator's genuine experience, so asking someone to praise a product they have not used is asking them to break the law.

The same applies to natural, clean and sustainability language, where a technically defensible word often carries an indefensible impression. Our explainer on what greenwashing is describes the mechanism, and our review of hair care claims works through a category where performance language and evidence part company particularly often.

Labelling the post as an ad: what the 2026 guide changed

The ASA, CAP and the CMA published a new edition of their joint Influencers' guide to making clear that ads are ads in October 2026. The core message is unchanged: if the creator received payment or any other incentive, or is commercially connected to the brand, the content has to be obviously identifiable as advertising, with a clear label upfront. What changed is the legal footing, which is now the DMCC Act and the CAP Code, plus a new section on fake reviews and new research. ASA research from February 2026 found that 79% of people in the UK think influencers should put ad labels where they can be seen straight away.

Use upfrontAdvised against
#Ad, #Advert, #Advertising, #Advertisement or #AdvertisementFeature. The hashtag is optional if the label is prominent and separate from other contentGift or Gifted; Affiliate, Aff, Af, Afflink or Collab; PR, PRTrip, PRHaul and similar
A platform branded-content tool, if it is upfront and prominentSponsored, Spon or Sp; Supported by, Funded by, In association with, In partnership with, Thanks to [brand]
On every story in a series, if the stories may be viewed separatelyJust tagging the brand; iworkwith, brandambassador, myedit, mycollection; a label hidden behind "more" or buried in a block of hashtags

A few points from the guide catch brands out. Disclosure continues for the whole of an ongoing relationship and for 12 months after it ends. Gifted product counts as payment, so "Gifted" alone is not enough. With affiliate links, both the creator and the brand are responsible, and if only some products in a post are affiliate-linked, the post has to make clear which parts are the ad. The ASA's affiliate marketing advice covers the detail.

A label does not cure a bad claim, though. "#Ad: this cured my acne" is a correctly labelled breach of the cosmetics rules and the CAP Code at the same time.

What to put in a creator brief

Reviewing content after it posts is the expensive way to manage this. Controlling the language that goes into the brief is the cheap way, and in our experience creators welcome it because it removes guesswork. A useful brief has eight elements:

Brief elementExample wording you can adapt
Approved claims, exact wording"You can say: 'formulated with ceramides to support the skin barrier' and 'leaves skin feeling softer'. Please use these as written."
Prohibited words, named"Please do not say: cures, treats, heals, repairs, prevents, medical grade, clinically proven, or name any condition such as eczema, acne, rosacea or psoriasis."
Personal experience"Talk about how it feels and how you use it. If you describe a result, make clear it is your own experience."
Timescales"No claims about how fast results appear unless we have given you the wording."
Visuals"No before-and-after content unless we agree the conditions first. No filters or edits on skin, hair or any area the product affects."
Genuine use"Only post a review once you have actually used the product. If something did not suit you, you can say so."
Ad label"Put 'Ad' at the start of the caption and on screen in the first frame of video. Keep it on for the life of the post."
Contact"Questions about wording go to [name, email] before posting. We would much rather answer a question than edit a live post."

If you want a single page to attach to every brief and contract, adapt this:

Brief insert: claims and disclosure (one page)

This is a cosmetic product. Anything you say about what it does counts as a claim, and we have to be able to prove every claim. Please keep to the approved wording below. If you want to say something that is not on the list, ask [name] first.

You can say: [approved claim 1]; [approved claim 2]; [approved claim 3].

Please do not say: cures, treats, heals, repairs, prevents, medical grade, clinically proven, or the name of any skin, scalp or medical condition. Do not promise results within a set time.

Show it honestly: no filters or edits on the area the product affects; no before-and-after without our written agreement on lighting, angle and timing.

Label it: "Ad" at the start of the caption and in the first frame of any video, for as long as the post is up. Replies to comments follow the same rules.

Keep the brief on file with the campaign. It is evidence of what you asked for, which matters commercially and if a particular post is ever questioned. Our list of claims that are not allowed is a good source for the prohibited words, and our review of commonly used cosmetic claims helps with the approved list. Every approved phrase should already have a row in your claims table with the evidence beside it.

Comments, DMs and live streams

The caption gets reviewed. The reply underneath it usually does not, and that is where the strongest claims in a campaign tend to appear. Someone asks whether the cream will help their rosacea, and a well-meaning community manager or creator answers "yes, it's amazing for that". That reply is a claim, made by or for the brand, about treating a named skin condition.

Give whoever answers messages a short script. The pattern that works is to describe what the product is formulated to do, decline to advise on a condition, and suggest the person speaks to a pharmacist or doctor about anything diagnosed. For example: "It's formulated to support dry, sensitive-feeling skin, but we can't advise on rosacea. A pharmacist or your GP is the best person to ask about that." Three or four prepared answers cover most questions, and they should be written by whoever owns claims rather than improvised at speed.

Live formats need the same preparation and get it least often. A live stream has no draft stage, so the only control is what the presenter already knows. Brief them on the prohibited words beforehand, keep the approved claims in front of them, and accept that an unbriefed guest may say something you would not have approved, which is a reason to correct it on air.

When something slips: takedown and the upstream fix

Something will slip, and the response matters more than the slip. Ask for the specific wording to be edited or the post removed, starting with anything you paid to promote, and keep a short record of what you found, when, and what you did. Do not simply end the relationship and leave the post up. A live post the brand paid for is a live claim the brand owns. A correction buried in the comments does not fix it either, because the overall impression is what gets judged.

Then look upstream. A single overstated caption is usually a brief problem or a product page problem rather than a creator problem, and the same wording is often already on your own website and marketplace listings. Marketplaces run their own claim screening on top of the law, and our article on what gets sellers flagged or removed on Amazon, Etsy and Shopify covers how that works. It is faster and blunter than a regulator.

Finally, keep the evidence you do hold organised enough to answer a question quickly. Our article on how claim substantiation works from lab test to legal file shows how to build that file, so a query about a caption becomes a filing exercise rather than a research project.

Selling into the US as well

If the same creators post for a US audience, the principles travel. The FTC's Endorsement Guides, 16 CFR Part 255, revised in 2023, say an advertiser can be liable for a misleading or unsubstantiated endorsement even when the endorser is not, and that brands should give endorsers guidance, monitor what they post and act on problems. One of the FTC's own examples is a skin care brand whose influencer says a body lotion "cures eczema": if the brand cannot substantiate that, it is liable whatever the influencer's position. On the classification side, the FDA says a product's intended use can be established by claims "in advertising, on the Internet, or in other promotional materials", so a creator's treatment claim can lead the FDA to regard a cosmetic as a drug.

Want an approved claims list your creators can work from?

Send us your product claims and the evidence you hold. We will give you the wording you can use, the wording you cannot, and a short brief insert your agency or creators can be handed directly. It is far quicker than reviewing content one post at a time.

Build your approved claims list Label and packaging review

Related reading

Myths we hear

  • The influencer said it, so the influencer is responsible. The Responsible Person must hold proof of the effect claimed. Where a brand commissions, pays for, gifts, scripts or amplifies content, it is the brand's advertising, and a contract between the parties does not change that.
  • Social media is not covered by the cosmetics claims rules. Article 20 names advertising expressly, and the common criteria apply to every claim however it is made. There is no lower standard for a caption, a reel or a story.
  • A genuine testimonial does not need substantiation. It shows one person had that experience. Presenting it as a general result is a performance claim, and the common criteria say an opinion must not be passed off as a verified claim.
  • If we did not pay for the post, it has nothing to do with us. Unsolicited mentions are not your advertising until you adopt them. Resharing, quoting, embedding on a product page or boosting a post makes the wording yours.
  • Writing #gifted covers us. The October 2026 influencer guide advises against "Gifted" as a label. Free product counts as payment, so the post needs a clear "Ad" label upfront.
  • A correction in the comments fixes an overstated claim. The overall impression is what counts. The claim has to be edited or removed, not qualified out of sight.

What to do this week

  1. Pull the last three months of commissioned and gifted content and list every claim made about your products, including comment replies.
  2. Match each claim to evidence you actually hold, and mark the ones you cannot support.
  3. Ask for overstated wording to be edited or posts removed, starting with anything you paid to promote, and log what you did.
  4. Write an approved claims list and a named prohibited words list, in exact wording.
  5. Add both lists, the ad labelling requirement, a filters rule and a named contact to every creator brief and contract.
  6. Give whoever answers comments and DMs three or four scripted replies for condition questions.
  7. Check your own website, product pages and marketplace listings for the same overstated wording.
  8. File briefs, approvals and takedown records with the campaign, alongside the claims evidence in the PIF.

Frequently asked questions

Do the cosmetics claims rules apply to influencer posts?

Yes. Article 20 of the Cosmetics Regulation covers advertising expressly, and the common criteria in Regulation (EU) No 655/2013 apply to any claim about a cosmetic product however it is made, including captions, video, overlays, comment replies and shoppable tags.

Who is liable if an influencer overstates what my product does?

The Responsible Person must hold proof of the effect claimed, and content the brand commissioned, gifted, paid for or amplified is treated as the brand's advertising. The ASA, CAP and CMA guide says everyone in the chain is responsible. A contract with the creator allocates risk privately but does not remove the brand's obligation.

Can a creator say a product cured their acne?

No. A claim to treat or cure a condition goes beyond a cosmetic claim, falls foul of the CAP Code rules on health and beauty claims, and risks the product being treated as a medicine. Name the conditions on the prohibited list in every brief.

Are before-and-after photos and filters allowed?

Before-and-afters are performance claims and need evidence with controlled conditions. Filters that alter the area the product affects have been ruled misleading by the ASA, so ban them on that area and agree before-and-after conditions in advance.

How should a paid or gifted post be labelled in the UK?

With a clear, prominent label such as #Ad or Advert at the start, before people engage. The October 2026 guide advises against Gifted, Sponsored, Spon and Sp. Disclosure continues through the relationship and for 12 months after it ends.

What should a creator brief contain?

Approved claims in exact wording, a named list of prohibited words, rules on timescales, filters and before-and-afters, a requirement that reviews reflect genuine use and personal experience is presented as such, the ad label format, and a named contact for questions.

Do I have to monitor organic posts about my products?

You are not expected to police every mention. You are expected not to adopt a claim you could not make yourself, so review anything before you reshare, quote, embed or promote it.

What should I do if a post has already gone live with a bad claim?

Ask for the specific wording to be edited or the post taken down, starting with anything you paid to promote, and record what you found and what you did. Then check whether the same wording appears on your own website and listings.

Official sources and legislation

S
Written by

Syed Muhammad Shamuel Shees

Founder & Lead Compliance Consultant

Phoenix Safety Consultants is a cosmetic compliance consultancy with offices in London, Tallinn and Pensacola. Our safety assessors and toxicologists prepare CPSRs, Toxicological Risk Assessments, PIFs, SDSs and UK/EU notifications for brands of every size. Talk to the team on WhatsApp or at compliance@phoenixcosmeticsafety.com.

Join the conversation