Skip to content
Qualified safety assessorsUK · EU · USA
Get a quote
  1. Home
  2. BLOGS
  3. Water Activity and the Anhydrous Myth: When a Product With No Water Still Needs Preserving, and How the Assessor Decides

Water Activity and the Anhydrous Myth: When a Product With No Water Still Needs Preserving, and How the Assessor Decides

Balms, scrubs, honey, aloe and hydrosols: why the real question is available water in use, not water in the recipe, and what your assessor writes in Part A

S Syed Muhammad Shamuel SheesFounder & Lead Compliance Consultant
11 min read
Reviewed by Phoenix Cosmetic Safety · Nov 10, 2026
Anhydrous mint lip balm tin, illustrating water activity and preservation of anhydrous cosmetic products

The short answer

A cosmetic needs preserving when microbes can grow in it, and that depends on available water (water activity), not on whether water appears in the recipe. Oils, balms, waxes and dry powders kept dry are low microbiological risk and normally need no preservative or challenge test, with a written justification. Sugar and salt scrubs and anything scooped with wet hands in a shower will meet water in use, so they need a tested preservative or packaging that keeps water out. Honey, aloe juice and hydrosols add water, so a product containing them is assessed as water based. The safety assessor records the reasoning in the microbiological quality section of Part A.

Key takeaways

  • The question is whether microbes will find usable water at any point in the product's life, not whether water was poured in.
  • Water activity measures that usable water; below 0.75 ISO 29621 treats a product as low microbiological risk, and below about 0.6 nothing grows.
  • Oils, balms, waxes and dry powders kept dry are low risk, but the CPSR still has to justify skipping the challenge test in writing.
  • Scrubs and other shower products meet water in use and need a tested preservative or a pack and directions that keep water out.
  • Honey, aloe juice, hydrosols and infusions add water; sugar, salt and glycerin slow growth but are not preservatives on their own.
  • Packaging, directions and the period after opening can change the assessor's conclusion for the same formula.

The sugar scrub had no water in it. Sugar, coconut oil, a splash of vanilla fragrance, whipped and potted in a pretty open jar. The maker was sure it needed no preservative, because every forum thread she had read said anhydrous products don't. Three months after launch a customer emailed a photo of black spots at the bottom of her jar. That scrub had spent its whole life on a shower shelf, scooped out with wet fingers, and every scoop had left a little water behind in a jar of sugar and oil.

The forum wasn't wrong, exactly. It was answering a different question. "Does this recipe contain water?" is easy. The question a safety assessor asks is harder: will microbes find usable water in this product at any point in its life, in the jar, in the bathroom and in the customer's hands? The term for usable water is water activity, and once you understand it, most preservation decisions stop being arguments.

Under Annex I of the Cosmetics Regulation, Part A of every safety report has to cover the microbiological quality of the product, including the results of a preservation challenge test where one is needed. That applies in the EU under Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 and in Great Britain under the same regulation as retained in UK law, which Trading Standards enforce through the Cosmetic Products Enforcement Regulations 2013. The Commission's guidelines on Annex I (Decision 2013/674/EU) then say when a challenge test can be left out, and that is where water activity earns its place.

Water activity in plain terms

Microbes need water, but they can only use water that is free. Water held tightly by sugar, salt or glycerin is not free. Water activity, written aw, measures that free water on a scale from 0 to 1, where pure water is 1.0. Technically it is the vapour pressure of water above the product divided by that of pure water, but you can think of it as "how thirsty would a bacterium be in here?"

The useful numbers are well established in food and cosmetic microbiology. Most bacteria stop growing somewhere below about 0.90. Most yeasts stop around 0.88 and most moulds around 0.80. A few specialist moulds and yeasts that like dry or sugary conditions keep going down to roughly 0.61, and below about 0.6 nothing grows at all, although spores can sit there and wait. ISO 29621, the standard assessors use to identify low microbiological risk products, treats a product with water activity below 0.75 as low risk, and lists anhydrous products as low risk too.

Water activity (aw)What can still growTypical cosmetic examples
1.00 to about 0.95Practically everything, including the bacteria that cause most cosmetic recallsLotions, creams, shampoos, toners, hydrosols, aloe juice
About 0.90Most bacteria are stopped below this levelVery concentrated sugar or glycerin solutions
About 0.88 to 0.80Most yeasts, then most moulds, stop in this bandSome syrupy, high humectant formulas
Below 0.75Treated by ISO 29621 as a low microbiological risk productLip balms, lipsticks, oil blends, many dry powders
About 0.61 to 0.60Only specialist moulds and yeasts that tolerate dry or sugary conditionsHoney, dried herbs
Below 0.60Nothing grows, although spores can surviveOils, waxes, butters, dry powders kept dry

This is why honey and dried herbs keep on a shelf for years even though they contain some water. It is also why the ingredient list alone can mislead you in both directions.

Two questions for every product

Is there free water in it now? Will there be free water in it while the customer is using it? A jar that starts dry and lives in the shower answers no to the first and yes to the second, and the second answer is the one that counts.

The genuinely low risk group

Oils, oil blends, balms, salves, butters, waxes, solid perfumes, lip balms, lipsticks, oil cleansers and dry powders contain no water. Kept dry, they give microbes nothing to work with. For these products the assessor normally records in Part A that the product is anhydrous, that it falls within the low microbiological risk category in Decision 2013/674/EU and ISO 29621, and that no challenge test is needed, with a short scientific justification. The guidelines are clear that the justification has to be written down; silence is not enough.

The justification usually rests on three things: no water bearing ingredients, packaging that does not invite water in, and use that keeps it that way. A lip balm in a stick or a small tin passes easily. For these products the real shelf life worry is rancidity, not bugs, so expect your assessor to ask about antioxidants such as tocopherol, light protection and your stability data rather than about preservatives. One caveat: dry powders and clays can carry spores from the raw material itself, so the assessor will still want a microbiological specification or certificate for those ingredients.

This is the group the forum had in mind, and for this group it is right. If you sell balms, our guides to the CPSR for lip balm and the CPSR for cleansing balms and oil cleansers go into the product specific detail.

Products that meet water in use

A sugar or salt scrub in oil is anhydrous in the jar and lives in the shower. Each use brings wet hands into it. Sugar and salt do lower the water activity of the water they dissolve in, which slows things down, but over weeks water collects at the bottom and around the edges, and the product starts to support growth. That is exactly what the customer photographed. The same logic applies to lip scrubs kept by a basin, whipped body butters used straight after a bath, and cleansing balms scooped with damp fingers.

Bath salts, bath bombs and bath melts sit slightly differently. They are used once and dissolved, so contamination during use matters less to the product itself. The risk there is storage: salts and bombs pull moisture from humid air, and a bath melt handled with wet hands can go the same way as a scrub. Our guides to the CPSR for bath salts and the CPSR for bath bombs cover those in more depth.

For shower and wet room products the assessor has three realistic routes, and the right one depends on the formula, the pack and the directions:

  • Preserve it and prove it. Add a preservative that works in the oil and water mixture that develops in use, then show it works with a challenge test. Standard methods such as ISO 11930 were written for ordinary water based products, so many labs run a modified test on a sample with water added to imitate shower use. Agree the method with your assessor before you book it.
  • Keep the water out. A squeeze tube, a pump or single use sachets, plus clear directions and a shorter period after opening, can sometimes support a preservative free product. Decision 2013/674/EU puts single use products and packs that cannot be opened in a middle category: no challenge test, but microbiological quality testing of the finished product is still needed.
  • Rely on single use and dry storage. For products such as bath salts, the assessor may conclude that dissolving the whole dose at once makes in use contamination immaterial, provided the pack keeps the product dry until then.

What you will not get from a competent assessor is a clean sign off for a preservative free scrub in an open jar destined for the shower. And honestly, you shouldn't want one.

Honey, glycerin, sugar, salt and the "waterless" botanicals

Most anhydrous confusion comes from a handful of ingredients that folk wisdom treats as preservatives. Each behaves differently once it is inside a cosmetic.

IngredientWhat people believeWhat happens in a cosmeticHow the assessor treats it
HoneyA natural preservativeHoney keeps because its own sugars tie up its own water. Stir a few percent into a balm and you add water without enough sugar to bind itA water bearing ingredient; the product needs a preservation rationale and usually a challenge test
GlycerinA preservativeOnly at very high levels does it pull water activity down far enough to matter. At normal humectant levels it simply draws moisture inLooks at the whole formula, not the glycerin; a water based product still needs preserving
SugarKeeps scrubs safeLowers the water activity of water that gets in, which slows growth, but cannot stop it once water pools at the bottom of the jarPreservative or water excluding pack required for shower use
SaltKeeps scrubs safeBehaves much like sugar, and can also corrode metal tins and lids over timeAs for sugar, plus a packaging compatibility check
Aloe juice, hydrosols, floral watersMake a product waterlessThey are water with a little plant material dissolved in it, and they often bring their own microbial loadA water based product; full preservative system and challenge test
Clays and botanical powdersDry, so nothing to worry aboutDry, but often carry spores and soil organisms from the raw materialAsks for a microbiological specification or certificate for the raw material

Honey deserves a special mention because it catches so many makers out. Honey itself sits at a water activity of around 0.6 because its sugars bind its own water, and it is usually well under 20 percent water. Put 5 percent of it into a balm and you have added water to a waterless product without bringing anywhere near enough sugar to bind it. The balm's risk goes up, not down. Glycerin works the other way round: at very high levels it can pull water activity down, which is part of why some glycerin rich products need less preservative, but that is a formulation decision backed by data, not something a few percent of glycerin gives you for free.

Then there is the "waterless" trend. Swapping water for aloe juice, a hydrosol or a herbal infusion does not make a product anhydrous. Those ingredients are water with some plant material in it, and they frequently arrive with their own microbial load. A product built on them is a water based product, it needs a proper preservative system (see our guide to Annex V preservatives) and it needs a challenge test like any lotion. If you genuinely want an anhydrous product, keep every water bearing ingredient out of it.

Packaging and directions: the levers you control

For borderline products, the pack and the instructions often decide the assessor's conclusion more than the formula does. An airless pump or a squeeze tube keeps out water that an open jar would let in. A spatula in the lid and a line on the label saying "use with dry hands" cut contamination during use. Single use sachets remove the in use question altogether. A shorter period after opening limits how long water has to build up.

The same formula can pass in a tube and fail in a jar, so tell your assessor exactly how the product is packed and how customers are told to use it. Photos help.

Ask yourself

Where will this product live, and what will be on the customer's hands when they use it? If the answer is a bathroom shelf and wet hands, it is not anhydrous in any sense that matters, whatever the recipe says.

What the assessor writes in Part A

The microbiological quality section of Part A should read differently for each type of product, and you should be able to recognise your product in it:

  • True anhydrous product: no water or water bearing ingredients; low microbiological risk under ISO 29621 and Decision 2013/674/EU; no challenge test, with the reasons stated; raw material specifications for any powders or botanicals; packaging and directions that keep it dry.
  • Scrub or shower product: anhydrous as supplied but foreseeably exposed to water in use; either a preservative shown to work in the water contaminated product, or packaging and directions that keep water out, with the period after opening set to match.
  • Product with honey, hydrosol or aloe: assessed as a water based product, with a preservative system, a challenge test and finished product microbiological results against the limits in the SCCS Notes of Guidance, which follow ISO 17516: no more than 1,000 colony forming units per gram for most products, and 100 for products meant for children under three, the eye area or mucous membranes. ISO 17516 was revised in 2026, so ask your lab which edition its report uses.

Part B then repeats and validates that reasoning, and its conditions, including any label warnings and the period after opening, follow from it. If your report says nothing at all about microbiology for a scrub, that is a gap worth raising. Our guide to cosmetic microbiological testing explains the finished product tests in more detail.

The sugar scrub, done properly

Back to our maker. She kept the sugar, the coconut oil and the vanilla, and added a broad spectrum preservative suitable for anhydrous systems that will meet water, at her supplier's recommended level. Her lab ran a challenge test on the scrub with a set amount of water mixed in to imitate shower use, and it passed. She moved from an open jar to a wide neck tube with a flip cap, added "use with dry hands and keep water out of the pack" to the label, and set the period after opening at six months.

Part A recorded all of that, Part B accepted the product with those conditions, and the black spots did not come back. She also launched a second scrub in single use sachets for her spa customers. That one needed no preservative and no challenge test, but it still went through finished product microbiological testing. Two products, two different reasons, and both decisions she can defend if Trading Standards ever ask.

A quick decision guide for your range

  • Oils, balms, salves, solid perfumes, dry powders: keep water bearing ingredients out, pack to exclude water, direct dry use, and get the low risk justification written into Part A.
  • Scrubs and anything used in the shower: preserve and challenge test with a water spike, or move to a tube, pump or sachet with clear directions and a shorter period after opening.
  • Bath salts, bombs and melts: pack and store dry; single use dissolution usually means no preservative, but watch humid storage.
  • Anything with honey, hydrosol, aloe juice or an infusion: treat it as water based; preserve it and challenge test it.
  • Anything sold as "waterless": check the ingredient list, not the claim.

Not sure which side of the line your product sits?

Send us the formula, a photo of the pack and how customers use it. We will tell you whether it can stay preservative free, what a challenge test would need to show, and what the assessor will want written down.

Book a consultation Order a CPSR

Related reading

Myths we hear

  • No added water means no preservative. What counts is usable water during the product's life, including water that gets in during use.
  • Honey is a natural preservative. Honey keeps itself, but adding it to a balm adds water to a waterless product.
  • Sugar keeps a scrub safe in the shower. Sugar slows growth; it cannot stop it once water pools in the jar.
  • Aloe juice makes a product waterless. Aloe juice is mostly water, and the product is assessed as water based.
  • Anhydrous products need no microbiology section in the CPSR. They need a written low risk justification; skipping the challenge test is allowed, skipping the reasoning is not.

What to do this week

  1. List every product in your range and mark any that contain water or a water bearing ingredient such as honey, aloe juice or a hydrosol.
  2. For each anhydrous product, write down where it is used and whether wet hands will touch it.
  3. Move shower scrubs to tubes, pumps or sachets, or add a preservative and ask your lab about a water spiked challenge test.
  4. Ask clay and botanical powder suppliers for a microbiological specification or certificate.
  5. Check that the microbiology section of each CPSR explains why a challenge test was or was not needed.

Frequently asked questions

Do anhydrous products need a preservative?

Usually not, if they truly contain no water and stay dry in use. Oils, balms, waxes and dry powders are treated as low microbiological risk. Products that meet water in use, such as shower scrubs, are the exception and normally need a preservative or packaging that keeps water out.

What is water activity in cosmetics?

Water activity (aw) measures how much water in a product is free for microbes to use, on a scale from 0 to 1. Pure water is 1.0. ISO 29621 treats products below 0.75 as low microbiological risk, and below about 0.6 nothing grows.

Do sugar scrubs need a preservative?

If they are used in the shower or scooped with wet hands, yes in most cases, or they need a tube, pump or sachet with directions that keep water out. Sugar slows microbial growth but does not stop it once water collects in the jar.

Does an anhydrous product need a challenge test?

Not normally. EU guidelines on Annex I allow the test to be left out for low microbiological risk products, but the safety report must state the scientific justification. Scrubs that will meet water usually need a challenge test, often on a sample with water added.

Does honey preserve a cosmetic?

No. Honey keeps itself because its sugars bind its own water, but a few percent in a balm adds water without enough sugar to bind it, so the product's microbial risk rises. Treat a honey containing product as water bearing.

Is a product made with aloe juice or a hydrosol waterless?

No. Aloe juice, hydrosols and floral waters are water with dissolved plant material, and they can carry their own microbes. The product is assessed as water based and needs a preservative system and a challenge test.

Do single use sachets need preservative?

Often not, because each sachet is used once and closed packs keep contamination out. The Annex I guidelines still expect microbiological quality testing of the finished product and a written justification in the safety report.

Where does the preservation decision appear in my CPSR?

In Part A, in the section on microbiological quality, which covers specifications, test results and any reason a challenge test was not needed. Part B then confirms the reasoning and sets conditions such as label directions and the period after opening.

Official sources and legislation

S
Written by

Syed Muhammad Shamuel Shees

Founder & Lead Compliance Consultant

Phoenix Safety Consultants is a cosmetic compliance consultancy with offices in London, Tallinn and Pensacola. Our safety assessors and toxicologists prepare CPSRs, Toxicological Risk Assessments, PIFs, SDSs and UK/EU notifications for brands of every size. Talk to the team on WhatsApp or at compliance@phoenixcosmeticsafety.com.

Join the conversation